Lodge 10.25" Cast Iron Skillet — BuySkip Verdict: BUY

Trust Score: 9/10

129 years old, made in Tennessee, costs less than a pizza — Lodge just doesn't miss.

BuySkip's analysis found this to be one of the clearest BUY verdicts in the cookware category. The Lodge 10.25" has been independently named best overall by Tom's Guide, Good Housekeeping, and Serious Eats after hands-on testing — and at ~$30, it outperforms pans costing 5-10x more. It's been made in the same Tennessee foundry since 1896, has 163,000+ Amazon reviews at 4.7 stars, and zero active CPSC recalls. The only real caveats: it's heavy (~5.5 lbs), the surface is slightly rougher than premium machined brands like Stargazer, and the handle gets screaming hot — grab the version with the silicone handle holder for a few extra dollars.

Key Findings

• 🚩 Rough textured surface (not machine-polished) — some users find it less nonstick than premium brands
• 🚩 Heavy at ~5.5 lbs — can be difficult to maneuver, especially for one-handed cooking
• 🚩 Handle gets very hot during use — the silicone handle holder version costs a few dollars more
• ✅ Named best overall cast iron skillet by Tom's Guide after hands-on testing — most affordable pick in the roundup
• ✅ CNET recommends Lodge as 'as safe a bet as there is' for cast iron — recognized legacy cookware brand
• ✅ Made in South Pittsburg, Tennessee since 1896 — 129 years of domestic manufacturing, not an overseas rebranding
• ✅ 163,000+ Amazon ratings at 4.7 stars — one of the highest-volume verified review counts in cookware
• ✅ No active CPSC recalls found — clean regulatory safety record

Sources

• Best Cast Iron Skillets — Tom's Guide
• Best Cookware Sets 2026 — CNET
• Lodge 10.25" Cast Iron Skillet — Amazon
• Lodge Cast Iron Skillet Review — Good Housekeeping
• Best Cast Iron Skillet 2025 — Serious Eats
• Lodge Cast Iron Review — The Flat Top King
• r/castiron — Lodge 10.25 discussion

Check another product on BuySkip