AG1 by Athletic Greens — BuySkip Verdict: HOLD
Trust Score: 6/10
Paying $79/month to maybe get nutrients you could get from a $12 multivitamin and an apple. Science is... pending.
BuySkip's analysis found that AG1 is a real, legitimate product from an established company — but the value case is shaky at $79–$99/month. The most damning issue: proprietary blends mean you likely can't confirm you're getting clinically effective doses of most ingredients, and a Reddit-based nutritional analysis suggests the bulk of each serving is pea protein, fiber, and spirulina — the remaining 43 ingredients may each get less than a trace amount. The prior formula contained EGCG linked to liver harm reports and has since been removed in the 'Next Gen' reformulation, with an active lawsuit currently in mediation. The NSF Certification for Sport is genuinely meaningful, but independent scientific reviewers found the marketing claims aren't backed by peer-reviewed evidence — and you're paying a massive premium to fund one of the most aggressive podcast sponsorship machines in supplement history.
Key Findings
- 🚩 Uses proprietary blends — exact doses of most ingredients are undisclosed, so clinical efficacy is unverifiable.
- 🚩 Reddit analysis suggests the bulk of each serving is pea protein, fiber, and spirulina — leaving ~1g for 43 other ingredients.
- 🚩 AG1's health benefit claims are not backed by peer-reviewed published evidence, per community scientific review.
- 🚩 Prior formula contained EGCG (green tea extract) linked to liver toxicity reports; removed in Next Gen reformulation.
- 🚩 Active lawsuit in mediation (Zimmerman Reed); some users reported hospitalization from adverse reactions.
- 🚩 Saturated with paid podcast sponsorships (Joe Rogan, Huberman, etc.) — heavy influencer marketing inflates perceived credibility.
- 🚩 At $79–$99/month, significantly overpriced vs. a quality multivitamin + probiotic stack costing under $20/month.
- ✅ Fortune editorial testers reported positive hands-on experience with taste, digestibility, and routine adherence.
Sources
Check another product on BuySkip